Tuning out, turning off: No Canadian teams in NHL Playoffs drives viewers away

by Angus Reid | April 6, 2016 8:30 pm

54% of regular playoff watchers say they’ll watch less, or not at all

 April 7, 2016 – When NHL commissioner Gary Bettman expressed hope[1] Canadians would stick with the Stanley Cup playoffs – even though odds were not looking good for a single qualifying Canadian team – his concerns were indeed well-founded.

The latest poll from the Angus Reid Institute suggests more than half of regular playoff viewers on this side of the border say they’ll either be watching less or tuning out completely.

With all seven Canadian clubs mathematically eliminated from playoff contention, the NHL team Canada’s hockey fans are most likely to throw their support behind instead is the defending champion Chicago Blackhawks.

Key FindingsAngus Reid Institute

No Canadian teams = fewer Canadian viewers

Though many may have been hoping it was merely a cruel April Fools’ hoax, the first of this month cemented a depressing reality: Canadian Stanley Cup hopes were gone, dashed prematurely and left to wait another year. This season marks the first time the NHL Playoffs will proceed without a Canadian team since 1969-70, when the only Canadian teams to hold a place in the league were Toronto and Montreal.

In this country, that hurts. As previously canvassed[2] by the Angus Reid Institute, 88 per cent of Canadians say that hockey is an important part of Canadian culture, a figure that includes 23 per cent who go as far as to say it “defines” our culture.
Now that fans’ dreams of winning the cup have transitioned to dreams of winning the draft lottery for consensus top pick Auston Matthews[3], what sort of effect will the absence of Canadian franchises have on their hockey-viewing habits over the next two months?

A majority (54%) of those who normally watch at least a couple of games during the playoffs say they’ll be watching less this year, including 19 per cent who say they won’t be watching at all. Considering an average of 1.5 million Canadians watched each game of the playoffs last year[4], this represents a significant exodus:

Angus Reid Institute

And it’s not just casual fans – those often drawn onto the bandwagon around playoff time – who say they’ll be changing their viewing habits this spring. Among those who say they follow the playoffs “very closely” most years, nearly half (46%) report that they’re less inclined to watch this season. The same can be said for viewers who normally follow “fairly closely.” Almost three-quarters (71%) of this group will watch less than usual, including one-in-five (21%) who say they won’t watch at all.

Notably, one-in-ten fans who usually watch the playoffs very closely (12%) say they’ll actually be tuning in more this year – perhaps freed of the stresses of cheering for their home team, or perhaps fans of an American team that made the tournament:

Angus Reid Institute

So if not Canada, then who?

Generally speaking, most Canadians are willing to set aside regional rivalries to support other Canadian teams in their pursuit of a championship. When asked if they find themselves cheering for other Canadian teams after their club is eliminated, more than half (57%) say yes, they want Canada’s teams to succeed.

Casual fans are most likely to take this approach, while diehards are more likely to say their support for Canadian franchises other than their own “depends” on the team in question (see summary tables at the end of the release).

But what about this year, when all of the Canadian teams are out of the running? When those who say they plan to watch the playoffs this season were asked to pick as many as two rooting interests from among the playoff-bound U.S. teams in each conference, most opted for a pair of Original Six squads:

Angus Reid Institute

Nearly half of respondents (46%) choose the defending champion Blackwawks, led by Canadians Jonathan Toews, Duncan Keith and Brent Seabrook, as the team they’ll support in the Western Conference. In the Eastern Conference, the Boston Bruins narrowly edge out Sidney Crosby and the Pittsburgh Penguins as the most-chosen option.

As noted in the infographic above, playoff-watchers’ allegiances in the Eastern Conference are more divided than in the west. They’re also more precarious. Two of Canadians’ four most-favoured teams in the east (Boston and Detroit) spent the last week of the season on the playoff bubble.

If nothing else, feelings about the Bruins and Blackhawks on this side of the border are polarizing, given that those two teams are also the ones Canadian viewers are most likely to likely cheer against. One-quarter (24%) of respondents who plan to watch this year’s playoffs say the Bruins are the team they will likely cheer against in the east, and 14 per cent say the same of the Blackhawks in the west.

Plenty of CanCon in the playoffs

If there is any good news for hockey fans, it’s that despite the absence of Canadian clubs, this year’s playoffs will still offer plenty of opportunities for patriotism. Roughly half (49.7%) of all players[5] currently in the league are from the Great White North, by far the most of any country. The next closest nationality, American, comprises just under one-quarter of the league’s population (24.2%).

And if Canadians are looking for a new team to hitch their wagon to, consider this: Of those teams still left standing, the St. Louis Blues and Florida Panthers feature the most Canadians on their rosters, with 16 apiece.

Angus Reid Institute


Canada’s best hope
Canada’s futility in pursuit of hockey’s Holy Grail has now reached 23 years. To put that into context, when Hall-of-Fame goaltender Patrick Roy hoisted the Stanley Cup on behalf of his Montreal Canadiens in 1993, Blackhawks captain Jonathan Toews was just five years old, the Berlin Wall had been down for less than four, and the Euro was still nearly a decade away from entering circulation.

Since then, Canadian fans have been teased – diehard fans may even say tortured – by failed trips to the finals: the Ottawa Senators lost to the Anaheim Ducks in 5 games in 2007, and devastating losses in the seventh game of the finals have befallen the Vancouver Canucks (1994, 2011), Calgary Flames (2004) and Edmonton Oilers (2006).
So, which team will be the one to break the streak? While there’s hardly a majority consensus on this question, the largest number of hockey followers (26%) say it will happen in la belle province. Indeed, more than twice as many say Les Habitants are this country’s best chance to end the drought and celebrate a championship once again as any other team:

Angus Reid Institute

While the Habs are the clear favourite among all hockey viewers, there’s a little more competition when this question is broken down by which team fans cheer for. Predictably, a much higher number of fans take the “homer” view when they’re asked about their own team.

Calgary fans are the most bullish – 58 per cent say their team has the best chance to win Canada’s next cup – though a similar number of Oilers (56%) and Canadiens (55%) faithful say the same. Things are less rosy in Winnipeg, as just under one-in-three (30%) say they’re Canada’s odds on favourite:

Angus Reid Institute

The Angus Reid Institute (ARI) was founded in October 2014 by pollster and sociologist, Dr. Angus Reid. ARI is a national, not-for-profit, non-partisan public opinion research organization established to advance education by commissioning, conducting and disseminating to the public accessible and impartial statistical data, research and policy analysis on economics, political science, philanthropy, public administration, domestic and international affairs and other socio-economic issues of importance to Canada and its world.

Click here for the full report including tables and methodology[6]

Click here for comprehensive data tables[7]

Click here for the questionnaire used in this survey[8]

Image – Klim Musalimov/Unsplash

Shachi Kurl, Executive Director: 604.908.1693

  1. expressed hope: http://www.cbc.ca/sports/hockey/nhl/nhl-playoffs-no-canadian-teams-1.3495523
  2. previously canvassed: http://angusreid.org/hockey-night-in-canada-dec2015/
  3. consensus top pick Auston Matthews: http://www.tsn.ca/tsn-mid-season-draft-ranking-topped-by-big-three-1.435206
  4. 1.5 million Canadians watched each game of the playoffs last year: http://www.thestar.com/sports/breakaway_blog/2015/06/canadians-tuned-out-stanley-cup.html
  5. half (49.7%) of all players: http://www.tsn.ca/canadians-do-not-make-up-the-majority-of-nhl-players-this-season-1.380861
  6. Click here for the full report including tables and methodology: http://angusreid.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/04/2016.04.07-Hockey-Playoffs.pdf
  7. Click here for comprehensive data tables: http://angusreid.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/04/2016.04.08_PlayoffsReleaseTables.pdf
  8. Click here for the questionnaire used in this survey: http://angusreid.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/04/Hockey-questionnaire.pdf
  9. shachi.kurl@angusreid.org: mailto:shachi.kurl@angusreid.org

Source URL: https://angusreid.org/nhl-playoffs/