Debt, savings, and stress: A study of economic experiences and attitudes in Canada today

by Angus Reid | January 27, 2019 10:25 am

Young Canadians are mostly pessimistic about their finances, but notably optimistic about retirement


January 28, 2019 – For every dollar of disposable income in Canada, Canadians owe roughly $1.78[1] to creditors. Collectively, Canadians hold more than $2 trillion[2] in debt, and a new public opinion poll from the Angus Reid Institute suggests this debt is causing notable financial strain for more than four-in-ten people in this country.

The study, conducted in partnership with The Globe and Mail, finds one-in-three Canadians (32%) have put off saving for retirement because of the debt they’re carrying. Millions more – especially those under the age of 40 – have put off buying a home (18%), getting married (8%), having children (7%) or moving out of their parents’ homes (5%).

On the savings side of the ledger, just 12 per cent of Canadians say they have an amount in the bank that meets or exceeds their personal goal.

Against this backdrop, most Canadians say they feel stressed about money, while younger Canadians voice concerns about their ability to find and keep good jobs.

That said, members of Canada’s Millennial generation are much less pessimistic when looking toward retirement. On average, the youngest Canadians expect to retire earlier and live better in retirement than their elders do. This, despite relatively few young Canadians reporting significant current savings.

More Key Findings:

 

INDEX:

Part 1: Economic attitudes in Canada today

Part 2: Debt and savings

Part 3: The age factor

 

 

Part 1: Economic attitudes in Canada today

Most people are stressed about money at least some of the time

A sustained period[3] of economic growth and decreased unemployment over the last few years has decreased the prominence of macroeconomic issues in the Canadian consciousness. In early 2016, “the economy” was – by a wide margin[4] – the most important issue facing Canada in the minds of Canadians.

In the three years since, the percentage of Canadians naming the economy as a top issue has declined significantly, replaced largely by deficits and government spending in the public consciousness:

That Canadians have been less inclined to see the economy as a major issue for the country doesn’t necessarily mean economic issues have been declining in importance in their personal lives, however.

This survey finds two-thirds of Canadians disagree with the statement “I’m never really stressed about money.” This finding is quite consistent across demographic groups. Even among those ages 55 and older – many of whom are retired and on fixed incomes – stressing about money is a regular occurrence:

One of the reasons Canadians find money issues stressful might be concern about finding and keeping a good job. While unemployment in Canada is low, wages have not been increasing[5]. This, coupled with the increasing precariousness[6] of work in many industries across North America, has a significant number of Canadians – especially those under age 35 – worrying about their ability to find and keep a good job:

Another source of money-related stress may simply be Canadians’ desire to build personal wealth. Most working-age Canadians disagree with the assertion that such goals aren’t important in life:

This perspective – that building wealth is, in fact, important – is particularly strong among young men, more than six-in-ten of whom disagree with the statement in question. Young women, on the other hand, are split: 49 per cent agree, and 49 per cent disagree:

Credit over cash; experiences over things

In addition to anxiety about jobs and money, another feature of Canadian household economics today is a preference for the intangible.

Nearly two-thirds of Canadians (63%) say they “hardly ever carry cash.” This includes full majorities across all age groups, as seen in the following graph.

Likewise, Canadians of all ages, led by those under 35, place less emphasis on owning physical objects and more on having experiences:

“It’s stupid to go into debt if you don’t need to”

Perhaps the most uniformly held economic attitude in Canada today is the belief that “it’s stupid to go into debt if you don’t need to.”

Nine-in-ten Canadians (89%) agree with this statement, and that proportion is consistent across all age groups.

Part 2: Debt and savings

Vast majority have at least some debt

Despite their reservations about going into debt, the vast majority of Canadians say they owe at least some money to someone.

Fewer than one-in-four Canadians (24%) are debt-free, as seen in the graph that follows:

The lighter debt-load described by Canadians between the ages of 18 and 34 doesn’t necessarily tell the whole story of how debt and age interact in Canada today. In order to incorporate the oldest members of the Millennial generation – defined for the purposes of this study as those born between 1981 and 1996 – ARI researchers expanded the upper limit of the youngest age cohort to 37.

Looking at the data through this lens, it becomes clear that the youngest respondents (those ages 25 and younger) have more in common with those in the oldest age group, while those between 26 and 37 have more in common with 38-55-year-olds in terms of their propensity to be carrying debt:

Among the 76 per cent of Canadians who have at least some debt, the pervading perception is that this debt is “significant, but manageable.” Four-in-ten Canadians (39%) describe their debt this way, while roughly one-in-six (16%) feel their debt is “difficult to manage.”

In addition to having more debt overall, people between the ages of 26 and 55 are more likely to perceive their debt loads as “significant,” as seen in the table that follows.

Most Canadians who have debt are carrying it on credit cards. Nearly six-in-ten Canadians who have debt (59%) say one or more credit cards make up a part of the amount they owe. The next most common types of debt include mortgages (39%), car loans (31%), and other loans/lines of credit (36%), each of which is carried by more than three-in-ten debt-holding Canadians.

Student loan debt is the second-most-common form of debt for Canadians ages 25 and younger, while mortgages are more common among those in the middle two age groups:

One-third of all Canadians have put off saving for retirement because of debt

The fact that most Canadians who have debt find it manageable belies the significant human costs many experience when attempting to manage it.

While only one-in-six Canadians (a number that still equates to more than 4 million people) say their debt is “difficult to manage,” a significantly larger number say they have put off saving for retirement because of their debt. Indeed, more than four-in-ten Canadians, overall, say they have put off at least one of the life experiences shown in the following graph as a result of the money they owe to creditors:

Those in the 26-37 age group are, again, among the most affected. Nearly four-in-ten Canadians in this age range (37%) have put off buying a home because of their debt loads, and roughly one-in-five (20%) have delayed marriage and/or having children (18%) because of it:

Many also say their debt has caused strife in their relationships. About a quarter of 26-37-year-olds who have debt say it has caused harm to their marriages (24%) or family relationships (22%).

Most have savings, but less than they would like

Whether it’s saving for retirement, an unforeseen challenge, or a major purchase, financial institutions make a concerted effort to encourage Canadians[7] to save, save, save. That, unfortunately, does not appear to be the trend among the Canadian public.

Asked how they feel their savings balance is currently, more than half of Canadians say they have a small amount, or no savings at all. Only 12 per cent of Canadians say they have an amount of savings that meets or exceeds their personal goal.

The group feeling most comfortable is those over the age of 55, while majorities of all age groups below that mark say that they have little to no savings:

Interestingly, savings appears to be more correlated with gender than debt is. While men and women of all ages report similar rates of indebtedness and similar perspectives on the manageability of their debt (see comprehensive tables for greater detail[8]), men – especially young men – are much more likely to feel that their savings are “significant” than women of the same age are:

Among the population who say they have at least some savings, the places in which they store this value are quite diverse. The most common holdings are chequing and savings accounts, though more than half say that they hold an RRSP or a TFSA:

The ability of Canadians to deal with an unexpected expense is varied. Perhaps unsurprisingly, older respondents are more likely to say they could manage over $1,000 in unexpected expenses (45%), though at least three-in-ten across all age groups feel this way. One-in-three 18-25-year-olds say that they would have difficulty dealing with an expense of $100 or less:

Again, there is a gendered component to these results. Women – perhaps reflecting their self-described lower levels of savings – are significantly less likely than men to say they could afford an unexpected expense of more than $1,000. This is true across all age groups, but the difference is again most stark among younger respondents:

While many Canadians appear unable to cope with an unexpected financial incursion – half overall say $500 or less would be unmanageable – the good news is many appear to have a safety net. Four-in-five among both the 18-25 and 26-37 age groups say that they have a source they could turn to if necessary. This drops for older age groups, but remains at two-thirds or higher:

Men and women are roughly equally likely to have a source they could turn to in the event of an unexpected money emergency (see comprehensive tables[9]).

 

Part 3: The age factor

The millennial balance sheet

As discussed in the preceding sections, the youngest Canadians and the oldest ones tend to have a fair amount in common in terms of their debts, savings, and financial outlooks. This is likely explained in part by those ages 25 and under having fewer expenses and fewer obligations as they start their adult lives, but it’s also likely a product of lower economic expectations on their part.

Consider, for example, a pair of questions from this survey that aimed to better quantify the assets and obligations of millennials, specifically (defined for the purposes of this survey as those ages 22 – 37).

Nearly two-thirds in this age group (64%) report having less than $25,000 in savings. This includes one-in-five (22%) who have no savings at all.

On debt, most 22-37-year-olds report roughly the same amount as they have saved. Fully seven-in-ten (70%) say they owe less than $25,000, with 26 per cent saying they have no debt at all:

That said, this question specifically asked about non-mortgage debt. As previously mentioned, Canadians ages 37 and younger are among those most likely to have put off buying a home because of their debt loads. Beyond that, it’s notable that among those in this age group who are homeowners, mortgages are more common, and the amount owed tends to be higher, as seen in the graph that follows.

Young homeowners’ greater mortgage debts don’t necessarily equate to greater home equity, however. Those ages 37 and under who own their homes generally owe money on properties that are slightly lower in value than average:

Many millennial homeowners had help from their parents when they first got into the market. Among young homeowners, 44 per cent had help from parents or other family members when making their first down payments. This was not true of as many 38-55 or 55-plus individuals.

Seeking financial assistance from family members is far from a universal behaviour among young Canadians. The youngest age group – those ages 25 and younger – are most likely to be counting on money from their parents or grandparents in order to make ends meet, but even among this group only slightly more than one-in-three (35%) agree with a statement to this effect, compared to 29 per cent of those under age 40 overall.

Pessimism about today, optimism about retirement

As shown in the preceding sections of this report, younger Canadians – particularly those between the ages of 26 and 37 – tend to be fairly pessimistic about the financial realities they face. They’re among those most likely to say they worry about finding and keeping a good job, and the vast majority experience money-related stress at least sometimes.

This pessimism is born out in some of the experiences they report in this study, as well. Younger people are more likely to view their debt as significant and – though they mostly feel this debt is manageable – they’re more likely to be putting other facets of their lives on hold (including buying homes, starting families, and saving for retirement) because of it.

Further evidence of this general attitude toward financial questions can be seen in a question asked only of those under age 40. A full majority of such respondents (56%) agree with the statement “I don’t think I’ll live as well as my parents’ generation did:”

Given these findings, it’s perhaps surprising that Canadian Millennials are quite optimistic about their prospects for retirement.

On the whole, younger Canadians expect to retire at younger ages than older Canadians do – though a notable one-in-five (18%) in the 26-37 age group say they never expect to retire. While this pattern makes intuitive sense, given that older people who are not yet retired must, by definition, retire later in life, it may also speak to unrealistic expectations on the part of younger respondents. Recall, for example, that more than four-in-ten Canadians ages 26-37 say they have put off saving for retirement because of their debt.

This disconnect becomes clearer when looking at expectations for quality of life once retired. While roughly one-third of those older than 37 say they expect making ends meet during retirement to be a struggle, those in the younger two age groups are much more likely to expect to have enough money to do everything they want to after concluding their careers.

How young Canadians plan to achieve this expected level of comfort in retirement is an open question. Though relatively few Canadian Millennials currently have more than $25,000 saved, most in this generation who expect to retire say they will do so using their own retirement savings, rather than money from the government or an employer. Older respondents, meanwhile, are more likely to anticipate funding their retirements through government or work pensions, and place less focus on personal savings or investments:

The Angus Reid Institute (ARI) was founded in October 2014 by pollster and sociologist, Dr. Angus Reid. ARI is a national, not-for-profit, non-partisan public opinion research foundation established to advance education by commissioning, conducting and disseminating to the public accessible and impartial statistical data, research and policy analysis on economics, political science, philanthropy, public administration, domestic and international affairs and other socio-economic issues of importance to Canada and its world.

 

For detailed results by age, gender, region, education, and other demographics, click here[10].

For detailed tables showing special age breaks, click here[11].

Click here for the full report including tables and methodology[12]

Click here for the questionnaire used in this survey[13]

 

MEDIA CONTACTS:

Shachi Kurl, Executive Director: 604.908.1693 shachi.kurl@angusreid.org[14] @shachikurl

Ian Holliday, Research Associate: 604.442.3312 ian.holliday@angusreid.org[15]

Endnotes:
  1. owe roughly $1.78: https://business.financialpost.com/personal-finance/debt/statistics-canada-reports-key-debt-ratio-ticked-higher-in-third-quarter
  2. more than $2 trillion: https://www.macleans.ca/economy/money-economy/canada-its-time-to-pay-off-that-debt/
  3. sustained period: https://globalnews.ca/news/4739555/canada-unemployment-rate-low-statistics-canada/
  4. by a wide margin: http://angusreid.org/federal-issues/
  5. have not been increasing: https://globalnews.ca/news/3531614/average-hourly-wage-canada-stagnant/
  6. increasing precariousness: https://globalnews.ca/news/4399615/professional-jobs-increasingly-precarious/
  7. encourage Canadians: https://business.financialpost.com/personal-finance/retirement/the-real-reason-people-fail-to-save-enough-for-retirement-and-what-you-can-do-to-limit-the-damage
  8. see comprehensive tables for greater detail: http://angusreid.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/01/2019.01.25-millennial-finance-release-tables.pdf
  9. see comprehensive tables: http://angusreid.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/01/2019.01.25-millennial-finance-release-tables.pdf
  10. click here: http://angusreid.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/01/2019.01.25-millennial-finance-release-tables.pdf
  11. click here: http://angusreid.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/01/2019.01.25-millennial-finance-special-RTs.pdf
  12. Click here for the full report including tables and methodology: http://angusreid.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/01/2019.01.28-millennial-finances.pdf
  13. Click here for the questionnaire used in this survey: http://angusreid.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/01/2019.01.25-millennial-finances-final.pdf
  14. shachi.kurl@angusreid.org: mailto:shachi.kurl@angusreid.org
  15. ian.holliday@angusreid.org: mailto:ian.holliday@angusreid.org

Source URL: http://angusreid.org/millennial-finance-debt-savings/